So, with that in mind, here are some of the reasons that you might decide to use one application over the other.įirst, let's look at the advantages Capture One still has compared to Lightroom: For others, Capture One’s rendering of raw files may be preferable to Lightroom’s. For example, for studio professionals, Capture One’s superior tethering and ability to work with sessions might be a feature they simply can’t live without. Having said all that, there are still things about Capture One that I still like and that I consider to be superior to Lightroom, that many people will still benefit from. I have to say that personally, the company’s recent decisions have given me pause about the direction it has chosen to take. Given everything I’ve written above, the question then becomes, do I still recommend Capture One? To be honest, I’m more reluctant to do so than I was previously. Given that some people switched to Capture One specifically because of Adobe’s subscription only options, this may be a bit frustrating and something of a let-down for those people. The upshot of this is that they are pushing people to the subscription model. Capture One claims that this is to move to a more regular update process and that they’re doing away with major individual updates. There will also no longer be update pricing, with this instead being replaced with a loyalty programme that gives you a discount depending on how long one has had the current version. Such users will get bug releases, but no new features until they purchase another new licence. Perpetual licence holders will no longer gain any new features after purchasing a licence. More significantly, though, Capture One has announced that it is changing the way it handles and charge for perpetual licences. The company has recently put up its prices and discontinued the manufacturer-specific versions, further raising the cost of entry. While the company has continued to add features in recent releases, personally I have found them underwhelming, although I appreciate that they appeal to others. Once you get used to this functionality, it significantly changes how you use Lightroom, and it’s very hard to go back to a workflow without these tools.Ĭapture One, on the other hand, has made less favourable changes recently. They have added the ability to use curves and in a recent update, Adobe has included an incredibly powerful new AI denoise tool. Not only that, but masks can be combined using basic Boolean functions to create complex dynamic masks. The AI tools allow you to select things like the sky and subject automatically, saving hours of manual masking. You can now use AI in addition to the traditional brush and gradient tools for creating masks. These include a whole new masking system, that now works almost like layers in Capture One, however with some significant advantages (as well as a few disadvantages). Because of this, I feel the advice and reasoning of my previous column no longer applies.Īdobe has re-worked the selective editing architecture of Lightroom and added significant new features. Since my last version of this post, Capture One has made significant changes to their licensing, and Adobe has added significant features to Lightroom. I’m also not trying to pick sides here (although I will give you my opinion as to whom I think is the current leader) but rather present the case for each as I see it, as best I can within my subjective view, and give you the reader enough information to help inform your choice. Some people will need some features more than others, and for some, a certain feature or lack thereof may be a dealbreaker. I fully understand that every photographer out there has different needs. It’s important to state what should be obvious here – that this is purely my opinion, based on my own experiences. One quick disclaimer – I’m mostly talking about Lightroom Classic here, as it still seems to be the most comparable and popular version of Lightroom, but many of the features mentioned are included in both versions. I feel that these changes require a whole new discussion, and therefore a whole new blog post. I’ve updated that article since the first version of it came out, and since I last updated it, there have been some significant changes in both Capture One and Lightroom. I tried to present a balanced opinion on the advantages and disadvantages of both. A while ago, I wrote an article on this blog my perspective on Capture One vs Lightroom, as I regularly use both applications.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
Details
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |